Mortgage Discrimination
On average in the United States, do people of different races with similar credit histories pay disparate mortgage costs?
Correct Answer
Contrary to the claims of many politicians, journalists, and activists, a 2019 study of mortgage costs by Federal Reserve Board economists Neil Bhutta and Aurel Hizmo found that whites, blacks, Hispanics, and Asians with similar credit histories pay “virtually identical” mortgage costs. The authors note that other studies that found racial disparities only examined interest rates and ignored upfront mortgage fees, which “can add up to thousands of dollars.” Bhutta and Hizmo found that black and Hispanic borrowers “tend to choose slightly higher interest rates in return for lower upfront costs,” while “Asian borrowers tend to select lower interest rates and pay more” upfront fees. Studies that fail to account for these upfront fees generate “misleading results about the presence of discrimination.” Claims of systemic racism in other realms, like income and education, suffer from similar flaws in that they ignore key factors that undercut their claims.
Documentation2019 StudyRace & IncomeRace & Education
Social Security Myths
This is the latest In Fact. Click the left arrow for earlier ones.One of the most pervasive political myths is that Social Security is in financial trouble because it has been “looted.”
Roughly 76% of voters believe that fiction, including 68% of Democrats, 84% of Republicans, and 75% of third-party voters. Here are the facts:
- What people call “looting” is a legal requirement established in the original Social Security Act of 1935, which mandates that all of the program’s surpluses be loaned to the U.S. Treasury and paid back with interest.
- With regard to claims that Social Security revenues are redirected to other programs, the Social Security Trustees Report explains, “The Social Security Act prohibits payments from” its “Trust Funds for any purpose not related to the payment of benefits or administrative costs for” Social Security.
- To determine if those laws are actually followed, Just Facts annually inspects, tabulates, and cross-checks the program’s annual receipts, expenditures, and assets to see if the books balance and if the Treasury has made the required interest payments to Social Security.
- Those investigations confirm that the books always balance and that the Treasury has always made the interest payments.
- Furthermore, the Treasury has been paying back the principal since 2020, which is why the Social Security Trust Fund has been declining since then and is due to become depleted in 2034.
- The primary driver of this pending insolvency is that the ratio of workers paying taxes to people receiving benefits has fallen by three times since 1955, and it is projected to fall further.
- The main cause of that dynamic is increases in life expectancy without comparable increases in the full retirement age. Today’s beneficiaries are collecting SS benefits for 37% to 41% longer than when the program began, even though the wealthiest age cohorts in the U.S. are now 65 years and older.
- Another less impactful dynamic is the increasing number of people receiving disability benefits, which account for 10% of all Social Security payouts. From 1965 to 2024, the U.S. population grew by 69% while the number of people receiving disability benefits increased by 379%.
- Many people believe that Social Security saves their money, but it is primarily a pay-as-you-go program that funds most of its benefits by taxing people who are currently working, much like a Ponzi scheme.
- Until people understand that, they will inevitably ask falsely premised questions like, “What happened to all of the money I paid in?”
- From there, they jump to falsely blaming others for stealing it, like politicians, immigrants, and “people who haven’t paid in.”
- Since Social Security was enacted, various Congresses and Presidents have passed more than 15 laws to increase the payroll tax rate and raise the maximum taxable wage faster than inflation, thereby violating the government’s original promise that the “most you will ever pay” is “3 cents on each dollar you earn, up to $3,000 a year.”
- Politicians have also enacted taxes on Social Security benefits that get funneled back into the program, thereby violating the government’s original promise that Americans will receive these benefits “regardless of the amount of property or income” they have.
- Yet, Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren & company allege that the rich aren’t paying their “fair share” into Social Security.
- In reality, the program is already a raw deal for high-income workers, and their inflation-adjusted maximum payroll tax is now 9.4 times the promised maximum.
- The falsehoods debunked above have created a socialistic cycle in which government continually imposes higher taxes, people become more dependent, and each generation of Social Security beneficiaries feels ripped off and entitled to more of the next generation’s paychecks.
- Regarding potential solutions that don’t further violate government promises, indexing the full retirement age to life expectancy would make the program sustainable for the foreseeable future.
- Also, allowing workers the option to change part of their Social Security involvement from a benefit program to a savings plan would likely give retirees far more money than the current program, and it would also be heritable, unlike the present system.
















