Question of the Day

Private Social Security

Would a pension system that is financially structured like Social Security be legal if carried out by a private corporation?

Correct Answer

Tell Me More

If a private corporation operated a pension system structured like Social Security, it would be illegal under laws that prohibit Ponzi schemes. Per the SEC, a Ponzi scheme "pays existing investors with funds collected from new investors." This is how SS operates. Contrary to popular belief, SS doesn't save people's money but pays beneficiaries mainly by taxing people who are currently working. In contrast, "federal law requires private pension plans to operate as funded plans" to increase "benefit security" and ensure "intergenerational equity." SS, on the other hand, has levied dramatically increased tax burdens on succeeding generations of Americans, thus creating severe generational inequality. And unless retirement ages are raised or benefits are reduced in some other way, taxes will need to be increased again to keep the program solvent. Also contrary to popular belief, the SS Trust Fund hasn't been looted, and no money has been diverted from SS to the SSI program.




Reload Question
Reload Question
Share via Facebook
Share via Twitter
Share via Email
Embed into your website
About the Fact App
Articles by Topic